Forum latest

Windows Home Server in depth: the Ars Technica review
Written by Daniel   
Monday, 15 October 2007 11:21
Windows Home Server in depth: the Ars Technica review

By Elle Cayabyab Gitlin, Joel Hruska, Kurt Hutchinson | Published: October 14, 2007 - 11:51PM CT
Home is where my server is

Microsoft Windows Home Server
Developer: Microsoft (product page)
System requirements: 1GHz processor, 512MB RAM, 70GB hard drive, Ethernet card
Price: $179-200 (OEM copies only)

When Microsoft announced Windows Home Server earlier this year, it was greeted with a mixture of curious disdain and eagerness. Some questioned what the product offered over existing solutions, while others welcomed it with open arms. It's at once hard to explain and easy to understand what Windows Home Server is, but it's worth getting to know the newest addition to the Windows family.

Over the years, we've cobbled together our own "home servers" using a variety of platforms and hacks to get the functionality we desired. Others have taken advantage of consumer-level storage devices such as Infrant's ReadyNAS or Data Robotics' Drobo to back up files and serve up media. These were haphazard at best, as it required piecing together both hardware and various software applications into a patchwork solution.

Windows Home Server is available through the following distribution channels:
As a complete hardware/software solution.
As OEM software for system builders.

Joe and Jane Public will likely walk into their local big-box electronics retailer and buy prebuilt machines that will have Windows Home Server already installed and configured for use. The test hardware we've used for this review is discussed in further detail later in this review, but for those of who want to roll your own, take a look at the Budget Box recommendations in our System Guides.

For those of you that were waiting on the OEM release, Microsoft is famously tight-lipped about system builder release dates and pricing, but several North American retailers have it in stock and ready to ship. As we noted, pricing has fluctuated as retailers look for the sweet spot, but it looks like our estimates of $150-200 weren't too far off the mark.
What Windows Home Server is

At first glance, Windows Home Server seems built to scratch an itch that doesn't exist. When Microsoft set out to make the business case for Windows Home Server, it quickly focused on a very specific target market: "Households with a broadband connection with 2 or more 'active' PCs that are sharing the internet connection." Additional research showed that on average, the majority of these households also had a digital camera, color printer, and a game console, but less than 20 percent reported feeling secure with their backup solution.

With Windows Home Server, Microsoft wants to simplify how your files and backups are stored. So far, so good, but what about the additional features: remote access, media sharing, etc.? Are they a tacked-on afterthought, or does Windows Home Server make everything play nicely together?

What Windows Home Server is not.... More     Comment in the Forum

Don't Click Here Don't Click Here Either